From The WaPo Via A & L Daily: Book review: ‘The Artist, the Philosopher, and the Warrior’ by Paul Strathern

Full review here (As long as it lasts)

History done with creative license:

“Strathern, a novelist and author of other popular histories, does for Machiavelli and da Vinci what he does for Borgia: creates a flesh-and-blood portrait for each that defies historical stereotype.”

Related On This Site:   Garrett Mattingly On Machiavelli-The Prince: Political Science Or Political Satire? From Nigel Warburton’s Virtual Philosopher: Machiavelli Is Always RelevantFriday Quotations: Machiavelli And The Founders

See Also:  Another inteersting Italian and a poem about Giordano Bruno by American poet Heather McHugh: What He Thought by Heather McHugh

Giordano Bruno In The New Yorker: The Forbidden World By Joan Acocella

Add to Technorati Favorites

Garrett Mattingly On Machiavelli-The Prince: Political Science Or Political Satire?

Full article here.

“The notion that The Prince is what it pretends to be, a scientific manual for tyrants, has to contend not only against Machiavelli’s life but against his writings, as, of course, everyone who wants to use The Prince as a centerpiece in an exposition of Machiavelli’s political thought has recognized…”

Mattingly (wikipedia), a historian, argues that this short work of Machiavelli’s overshadows his attempts at plays, poems and prose, and overlooks the following:

“‘…Popular rule is always better than the rule of princes.’ This is not just a casual remark. It is the main theme of the Discorsi and the basic assumption of all but one of Machiavelli’s writings, as it was the basic assumption of his political career.”

Well, perhaps Machiavelli did really believe in the traditional virtues (Christian, Aristotelian?) and thus did not truly question those traditional beliefs…

…and instead perhaps The Prince should be viewed more as work of art in the vein of his other works (and not as philosophy necessarily?) as Mattingly argues…

Are you convinced?

See Also On This SiteFrom Nigel Warburton’s Virtual Philosopher: Machiavelli Is Always RelevantFriday Quotations: Machiavelli And The Founders

Niccolo Machiavelli by Crashworks

Add to Technorati Favorites

From Nigel Warburton’s Virtual Philosopher: Machiavelli Is Always Relevant

Full post here, which is brief.

You’ll encounter extremely profound and highly practical advice for those who find themselves in power.   I’ve heard it argued that he was quite moral (I’m not entirely convinced), in that he encouraged wise rule by compiling such insight all in one place.  (see the previous post on justice and Thrasymachus).  

Stanford Encyclopedia Of Philosophy’s Machiavelli entry, which begins with an argument as to why it’s necessary to include him.

Niccolo Machiavelli by Crashworks

by Crashworks

Add to Technorati Favorites