More On The Kant-Fichte Argument…What Was Hume Doing?

I brought up Bertrand Russell’s criticism of Kant in his History of Western Philosophy, and here’s a brief defense of what Kant was likely trying to do:

David Hume’s metaphysics were penetrating enough, and as Wikipedia (the absolute authority) has it:

Hume thus concludes that our inductive practices have no rational foundation, for no form of Reason will certify them.”

We come to know the world very well through inductive reasoning, but this is not connected to our reason according to Hume, it is merely an intuitive and experiential means by which we understand the world, which is in turn enfolded by Nature. 

Kant speculated that this argument can lead, if one follows it, to a denial of reason itself, and more importantly, a world we are actually coming to know outside of ourselves.   Kant did more than any philosopher to categorize our own intuitive processes to show the limits of our reason,  but he also believed we could come to real knowledge of things (the problem is his arguments for empirically real things aren’t so good) through our reason.  His critique is merely a survey of what he thought those limits of reason were.

As Russell has Kant, he’s merely yet another philosopher floating somewhere between science and religion, doing a lot to update traditional metaphysics, theology, thinking about science…and other fields…but errantly placing reason upon a pedestal of transcendence as have so many before him (not least of all because of the Germany he was a part of).

Kant probably thought he was saving science from the errors he saw in both Hume and Leibnizian rationalism. 

Here’s a Rationalism/Empiricism page at Stanford which says much of what I’ve tried to say here…probably better.

Add to Technorati Favorites

Hurricanes By Popular Demand

Here are some hurricane links I’ve found:

1. A Brief Overview-It’s for kids, but go ahead, swallow your pride.

2. The National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration

3. The Red Cross-How to Prepare

4. The Weather Channel-One of the best places to track hurricanes once they form.

Here’s one cool photo to check out.

Here’s a video of Hurricane Dean from space (it’s enormous) and here are some people feeling the force of hurricane winds.

Also, read about the deadly Key West hurricane here.

Addition:  Here’s a good link to the 10 most deadly hurricanes.  Click here for some NASA fun.

hurricane.jpg

Add to Technorati Favorites

Goya’s Fight With Cudgels

Here is the painting.

As part of Goya’s black period, he seems to have been exasperated with his own lot as well as what he’d observed of the human condition.   The same fluid brushstroke style is there, the same dark tones (though the sky still seems a transcendent, slightly mystic blue and white) but the theme is dark….

Is this a painted over scene…the confused images of bitter old age and loss of memory that can come with it?   

Is it a faithful recording of the ignorance, fear and brutality he saw in Spain during his lifetime?

Here’s a quote from this excellent Goya page:

“Fantasy abandoned by reason produces impossible monsters: united with her, she is the mother of the arts and the origin of their marvels.”

“La fantasia abandonada de la razon, produce monstruos imposibles: unida con ella, es madre de las artes y origen de sus marabillas.”

But what was reason for Goya? 

See also: A previous Goya’s Colossus post.

Add to Technorati Favorites