I don’t know how you ended-up on this blog, but here you are: Welcome old and new readers, to this little carved-out corner of the web. May you subtly calculate how and why you disagree with me as you click back to that latest favorite video/recipe/game.
Or do yourself a favor and just click through to Zombo.com already.
Personally, I see many Wild-West attributes of online platforms as increasingly coming into contact with existing institutions and interests, and becoming less wild, but still Western.
This seems to be happening while many of our institutions have been seriously over-leveraged and are undergoing tremendous populist pushback. Trust in political parties, lawmakers and institutional leadership are at all-time lows.
Is America becoming more like Europe?
Mid and longer-term, there is still a fair amount of high-end innovation and intellectual incubation going on. I tend to see mathematicians, AI innovators, computer scientists and software engineers as trying to solve particular kinds of problems, and generally not worrying too much about ‘culture,’ at least while not actively solving these problems.
Nevertheless, the ‘culture’ is interested in them. At many companies and institutions, there is a tendency towards aligning with the loudest voices and most committed social reformers, which is to say favoring oppressed identity groups (women, minorities etc) on a rather simplified trend-line towards ever-more freedom and progress.
This tends to be where a lot of moral and public sentiment is currently being directed, regardless of deeper truths.
Such platforms also interact with a general decline in organized religious and cultural expectations in nearly all of our lives (my simplified trend-line of less religion in our lives). I see a good deal of increased choice and freedom about where to work, whom to marry and how to make decisions these days.
Therefore, not all of these changes are bad. Many of these changes, in fact, have been very good for very many people, but they come with costs.
It’s not clear what the new rules are nor upon which foundations they will rest.
What’s going on with the intellectual dark-web?: If not all change is for the better, and if you’re counting on liberation driven by radicals decrying all existing institutions in favor of utopian ideas and revolution, then you’re counting on deeply authoritarian and totalitarian ideologues to defend liberty.
This is where many in academia, the media and positions of cultural influence find themselves these days, having backed-into into institutional and bureaucratic capture by illiberal voices.
As for the current Patreon dustup, I see Patreon as primarily having to make a business decision in the ‘culture’ wars between the more activist and socialist Left and the IDW (intellectual dark-web).
A vigorous, robust defense of freedom of speech so common a generation ago has now sadly, but unsurprisingly, become a cultural battleground.
And on major platforms like Patreon, the IDW folks standing-up for broader and more open speech have become an unprotected minority, and likely a business liability:
Many deeply committed socialists tend to be surprisingly good art and film critics, focusing sharply on ‘culture.’ Many economic Marxists tend to congregate in the academy and politics as they produce little of value beyond spreading the gospel of Marx. They can be particularly adept at politics, gaining special traction while institutions are over-leveraged.
If you allow them to drive the latest moral idea, then eventually standing up for any law, tradition or practice makes you an enemy and part of the ‘system’ they claim to know so much about:
As for my take on artists, most good ones tend to the bohemian, operating on the fringes of the ‘culture’, wanting to develop particular skills, talents as well as their own unique voices (good artists earn appropriate respect for their skills and talents, despite often harboring fruitcake economic and philosophical ideas).
Generally, they are not members of a ‘creative class,’ as this tends to be a favored fiction of many a softly collectivist type, dreaming rosy dreams.
More broadly, many in the culture at large have gone down deeply nihilistic and existentialist pathways. On the ‘cutting-edge’ where what’s cool easily becomes culturally and politically influential, many individuals see themselves as bitterly isolated from all meaning and purpose, on their own against the void, much like the tragic anti-hero become so popular these days.
I see this as occuring on a much longer trend-line, or at least, Isaiah Berlin offers some useful thoughts as to when and where Western artists started adopting this Romantic vision and outside-looking-in approach so common these days:
As to my own paltry contributions (using other people’s platforms to link to other people discussing past great contributions), here ya go.
There are many entry points into Western canon, so here are just a few:
Music + Math=Symmetry?:
And just a passing dream: